FREE QUOTEWhen building or renovating in Melbourne, one of the biggest decisions you’ll make is your roofing material. Do you go the classic route with tiled roofing, or embrace the modern and durable appeal of metal? While both options have their place, the long-term value of each varies depending on your priorities — and your postcode.
A Look at What You’ll Learn
This post breaks down the cost, lifespan, maintenance, and overall value of metal roofing versus traditional tiles. We’ll also explore how each performs in Melbourne’s unique climate and which option may give you more bang for your buck in the long run.
The Real Difference Between Metal and Tile Roofing
1. Initial Cost
Tile roofs (typically made of terracotta or concrete) often have a lower material cost than premium metal roofing. But installation can be more labour-intensive due to their weight. Metal roofs, particularly Colorbond, may cost more upfront but are quicker and cheaper to install.
2. Durability and Lifespan
Tiles can crack under pressure — from fallen branches, hailstorms, or even foot traffic. Metal roofs, on the other hand, are highly resistant to impact and corrosion. A Colorbond roof can last up to 50 years with minimal maintenance, while tiles often require periodic replacement or repair.
3. Maintenance Requirements
Tiles are notorious for shifting or breaking over time, especially on older roofs. Moss growth can also be a common issue in Melbourne’s damper months. Metal roofs are low-maintenance, with a simple hose-down being enough in most cases.
4. Weather Performance
Melbourne’s climate throws everything at a roof — UV, rain, hail, and wind. Metal roofing handles all of it like a pro. Tiles can absorb moisture and are more prone to leaks if not maintained properly.
5. Energy Efficiency
Both materials can be insulated, but modern metal roofing with reflective coatings (like Thermatech® in Colorbond) helps deflect heat and improve home energy efficiency.
6. Resale Appeal
Metal roofs tend to offer a modern, sleek aesthetic that appeals to today’s homebuyers. That can translate to higher resale value, especially in newer suburbs and urban infill areas.
Questions Homeowners Often Ask
Q: Do metal roofs get hotter in summer?
Modern metal roofs are designed to reflect heat, not absorb it. They can actually help reduce cooling costs when properly insulated.
Q: Are metal roofs louder in the rain?
Not with good insulation! A properly installed metal roof isn’t noticeably louder than tile. More on that in an upcoming post.
Q: How do long-term costs compare?
Though metal roofing can cost more upfront, it usually offers lower maintenance and longer life, meaning you’ll spend less over time. Curious what a metal re-roof might cost? Here’s a handy guide: metal roof replacement costs.
Which One’s Right for You?
In the long run, metal roofing — particularly Colorbond — often delivers better value. It’s tougher, lasts longer, and suits both modern and traditional homes. That’s why more Melbourne homeowners are making the switch.Whether you’re building from scratch or looking to upgrade, a chat with ELR Roofing can help you weigh up your options and get a quote that fits your plans and budget.